|
Feature
|
Servo-Hydraulic Tester
|
Servo-Electric Tester
|
|---|---|---|
|
Driving Force
|
Pressurized Hydraulic Oil
|
Electric Servo Motor
|
|
Max. Force
|
Very High (up to multi-Meganewtons)
|
Low to Medium (typically up to ~500 kN)
|
|
Dynamic Performance
|
High force at high frequency, long stroke
|
Very high frequency at small stroke/force
|
|
Operating Cost
|
High (power, oil, maintenance)
|
Low (mainly electricity)
|
|
Noise Level
|
Very Noisy (power pack)
|
Quiet
|
|
Cleanliness
|
Risk of leaks, oily, hot
|
Clean, cool, no leaks
|
|
Precision/Control
|
Very Good
|
Excellent (especially at low forces)
|
|
Stiffness
|
System dependent, frame critical
|
Inherently high
|
|
Complexity
|
High (hydraulic system)
|
Lower (electro-mechanical)
|
|
Feature
|
Fatigue Test
|
Impact Test
|
|---|---|---|
|
Stress Type
|
Repeated, cyclic stress (long-term)
|
Sudden, high-force impact (single event)
|
|
Test Goal
|
Evaluate long-term durability
|
Evaluate crashworthiness
|
|
Failure Mode
|
Cracks, permanent deformation from repeated use
|
Catastrophic breakage or separation from impact
|
|
Standards Requirement
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|
|
Feature
|
Fatigue Test
|
Impact Test
|
|---|---|---|
|
Stress Type
|
Repeated, cyclic stress (long-term)
|
Sudden, high-force impact (single event)
|
|
Test Goal
|
Evaluate long-term durability
|
Evaluate crashworthiness
|
|
Failure Mode
|
Cracks, permanent deformation from repeated use
|
Catastrophic breakage or separation from impact
|
|
Standards Requirement
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|
|
Feature
|
Servo-Hydraulic Tester
|
Servo-Electric Tester
|
|---|---|---|
|
Driving Force
|
Pressurized Hydraulic Oil
|
Electric Servo Motor
|
|
Max. Force
|
Very High (up to multi-Meganewtons)
|
Low to Medium (typically up to ~500 kN)
|
|
Dynamic Performance
|
High force at high frequency, long stroke
|
Very high frequency at small stroke/force
|
|
Operating Cost
|
High (power, oil, maintenance)
|
Low (mainly electricity)
|
|
Noise Level
|
Very Noisy (power pack)
|
Quiet
|
|
Cleanliness
|
Risk of leaks, oily, hot
|
Clean, cool, no leaks
|
|
Precision/Control
|
Very Good
|
Excellent (especially at low forces)
|
|
Stiffness
|
System dependent, frame critical
|
Inherently high
|
|
Complexity
|
High (hydraulic system)
|
Lower (electro-mechanical)
|
|
Feature
|
Servo-Hydraulic Tester
|
Servo-Electric Tester
|
|---|---|---|
|
Driving Force
|
Pressurized Hydraulic Oil
|
Electric Servo Motor
|
|
Max. Force
|
Very High (up to multi-Meganewtons)
|
Low to Medium (typically up to ~500 kN)
|
|
Dynamic Performance
|
High force at high frequency, long stroke
|
Very high frequency at small stroke/force
|
|
Operating Cost
|
High (power, oil, maintenance)
|
Low (mainly electricity)
|
|
Noise Level
|
Very Noisy (power pack)
|
Quiet
|
|
Cleanliness
|
Risk of leaks, oily, hot
|
Clean, cool, no leaks
|
|
Precision/Control
|
Very Good
|
Excellent (especially at low forces)
|
|
Stiffness
|
System dependent, frame critical
|
Inherently high
|
|
Complexity
|
High (hydraulic system)
|
Lower (electro-mechanical)
|
|
Feature
|
Fatigue Test
|
Impact Test
|
|---|---|---|
|
Stress Type
|
Repeated, cyclic stress (long-term)
|
Sudden, high-force impact (single event)
|
|
Test Goal
|
Evaluate long-term durability
|
Evaluate crashworthiness
|
|
Failure Mode
|
Cracks, permanent deformation from repeated use
|
Catastrophic breakage or separation from impact
|
|
Standards Requirement
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|
|
Feature
|
Servo-Hydraulic Tester
|
Servo-Electric Tester
|
|---|---|---|
|
Driving Force
|
Pressurized Hydraulic Oil
|
Electric Servo Motor
|
|
Max. Force
|
Very High (up to multi-Meganewtons)
|
Low to Medium (typically up to ~500 kN)
|
|
Dynamic Performance
|
High force at high frequency, long stroke
|
Very high frequency at small stroke/force
|
|
Operating Cost
|
High (power, oil, maintenance)
|
Low (mainly electricity)
|
|
Noise Level
|
Very Noisy (power pack)
|
Quiet
|
|
Cleanliness
|
Risk of leaks, oily, hot
|
Clean, cool, no leaks
|
|
Precision/Control
|
Very Good
|
Excellent (especially at low forces)
|
|
Stiffness
|
System dependent, frame critical
|
Inherently high
|
|
Complexity
|
High (hydraulic system)
|
Lower (electro-mechanical)
|
|
Feature
|
Fatigue Test
|
Impact Test
|
|---|---|---|
|
Stress Type
|
Repeated, cyclic stress (long-term)
|
Sudden, high-force impact (single event)
|
|
Test Goal
|
Evaluate long-term durability
|
Evaluate crashworthiness
|
|
Failure Mode
|
Cracks, permanent deformation from repeated use
|
Catastrophic breakage or separation from impact
|
|
Standards Requirement
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|
Required by ISO 4210, EN 17128, ISO 13232
|